Tom Hulce

Mickey Schwerner

Jennifer Grey

Rita Schwerner

Blair Underwood

James Chaney

CCH Pounder

Fannie Lee Chaney

Andre Braugher

Dennis

Josh Charles

Andrew Goodman

Walton Goggins

Lyle

Greg Kinnear

News reporter

John Dennis Johnston

Hatchet-Faced Man

Donzaleigh Abernathy

Sue

Royce D. Applegate

Deputy Winter

Harry Caesar

Hollis Watkins

Lou Walker

Scott Lawrence

Matt Suarez

Eugene Byrd

Ben Jr.

J. Don Ferguson

Jill Jane Clements

Ida Flowers

Thom Gossom Jr.

Charlie Parham (as Thom Gossom)

Bill Coates

Rev. Jenkins

Ted Manson

Wilbur Combs

Tanzia Franks

Barbara Chaney